Material Select update/destroy options for a specific mdb-se

Expected behavior

Im trying to conditionally populate an mdb-select dropdown based on certain logic. According to the docs, in order to update an mdb-select, you must first destroy the select, then reinitialize. The problem is, the destroy function doesnt seem to be working. If you look at the image below, you can see that the newly defined options are just being appended to the original mdb-select options.

Resources (screenshots, code snippets etc.)

<select class="mdb-select dropdown-info" id="chart_type_filter">
     <option value="bar">Bar</option>
      <option value="line">Line</option>
 </select>

<select class="mdb-select dropdown-info" editable="true" id="income_currency_filter">
 <option value="A" id="income_currency_A">A</option>
 <option value="B" id="income_currency_B">B</option>
 <option value="C" id="income_currency_C">C</option>
</select>

<script>
//first logic check
if (some logic is true){
    //remove 'A' option
     $('#income_currency_filter').materialSelect({destroy: true });
    $('#income_currency_filter').append('<option value="B">B</option>'); 
    $('#income_currency_filter').append('<option value="C">C</option>'); 
    $('#income_currency_filter').materialSelect();
}
//second logic check
 else if (some other logic is true){
    //remove 'B' option
     $('#income_currency_filter').materialSelect({destroy: true });
    $('#income_currency_filter').append('<option value="A">A</option>'); 
    $('#income_currency_filter').append('<option value="C">C</option>'); 
    $('#income_currency_filter').materialSelect();
}
</script>

before first logic check

after first logic check